November 03, 2024non toxic living

My Honest Primally Pure Review: Pros & Cons

This page may contain affiliate links. We may earn a commission on purchases, at no additional cost to you. Learn more →

My journey with Primally Pure* started when I was deep into researching clean beauty products. I’d been hunting for natural products that were genuinely non-toxic, effective, and natural—a difficult combination to find. So many brands out there promise “natural” ingredients, yet a closer look at the label often tells a different story, with sneaky toxic chemicals hidden in fine print. When I came across Primally Pure, I felt like I’d found something different.

I care deeply about what goes on my skin, especially since switching (gradually) to a non-toxic lifestyle, so I wanted to test if Primally Pure lived up to the hype. I couldn’t wait to see how their products worked in my routine. I tested these three Primally Pure essentials: the Unscented Sensitive Deodorant, Plumping Face Mask, and Plumping Serum. Each of these promised something unique—gentle, natural care with clean, recognizable ingredients.

In this review, I’ll dive into my personal experience with each of these products—the good, the not-so-good, and whether they’re worth a spot in your natural skincare routine, especially if you’re dealing with sensitive skin conditions.

Why Primally Pure? My First Impressions

What drew me in was how simple and straightforward Primally Pure’s approach is—no endless lists of “greenwashed” ingredients or overwhelming options. I noticed right away that their products were formulated with minimal, recognizable ingredients.

To start, I chose the Unscented Sensitive Deodorant*, the Plumping Face Mask*, and the Plumping Serum*. I was especially excited about the deodorant. Finding a natural deodorant that actually works and doesn’t irritate my skin has been an endless journey (and I’m sure I’m not alone here!).

With the face mask and serum, I was curious if they could deliver on the hydration and plumping effects they promised without being overly heavy or greasy—especially on my aging skin, which craves nourishment, hydration, and a bit of that youthful plumpness.

I’ll share my honest impressions of how each one performed, what I loved, and any quirks that came along with them. Let’s go!

Primally Pure* Review: Product Reviews

Here, I’ll walk you through my experience with three of Primally Pure’s top products: the Unscented Sensitive Deodorant, Plumping Face Mask, and Plumping Serum. Each product is carefully crafted, and I’ll share how they performed for me, as well as some tips on how to get the best results from each.

Primally Pure Deodorant Review: Unscented Sensitive*

If you’ve tried natural deodorants before, you probably know it’s a journey. Some work for a day, others leave skin irritated, and many just don’t quite deliver.

I usually opt for scented deodorants to help mask any odor, so I was a bit skeptical about going unscented. With an unscented option, there’s nothing to “cover up” odor—so it really has to work. So Primally Pure’s Unscented Sensitive Deodorant was definitely a game-changer for me.

Bethany McDaniel, the founder, has said, “We wanted to create something gentle enough for all skin types but tough enough to really work”—and for me, it definitely lived up to that promise.

This formula combines baking soda, coconut oil, organic arrowroot powder, non-nano zinc oxide, and kaolin clay for strong odor protection without essential oils or artificial fragrances that can irritate sensitive skin.

My Experience

From day one, I noticed that this deodorant kept me fresh all day without any scent, which turned out to be refreshing. It felt light and didn’t cause any redness or itching, unlike other baking soda-based deodorants that can sometimes be harsh.

The only downside is that it can leave some white residue on clothing, especially darker fabrics. To minimize this, I recommend applying a thin layer and allowing it to dry completely before dressing.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Long-lasting odor control, gentle on sensitive skin, free from fragrances and essential oils.

• Cons: Those with very sensitive skin might still feel some dryness, so pairing it with a light moisturizer can help. Can leave white marks on dark clothing.

**Plumping Mask*: A Hydrating Boost for Tired Skin**

Next up is the Plumping Face Mask*, a product I’d been eager to try for its promise of hydration and glow.

Ingredients and Formula

Packed with hydrating ingredients like honey and botanicals, this face mask also has a beautiful natural fragrance that’s not overwhelming but definitely adds a nice sensory experience to the routine. The texture is rich and honey-like, perfect for a mask you want to leave on and let your skin absorb fully.

My Experience

After applying a thin layer and leaving it on for about 15 minutes, my skin felt instantly softer and more hydrated! I usually apply masks directly after a sauna session to give my skin an extra boost, and this one fits perfectly into that ritual. The mask also has a subtle, minty cooling sensation on the skin, which I found incredibly refreshing—it adds a nice, invigorating touch, especially when my skin feels tired. While it’s too early to say if it’ll have long-term plumping effects, I could see this being a great addition whenever my skin needs a hydration boost. And it smells amazing!

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Luxurious texture, instantly hydrates and softens, gives a temporary plumping effect.

• Cons: The amount is also quite small, so it may not last as long if used frequently.

primally pure product review Plumping Mask

Plumping Serum*: Lightweight Yet Deeply Hydrating

The Plumping Serum* was my final pick from Primally Pure, chosen for its hydrating and skin-smoothing benefits.

Ingredients and Formula

This serum combines ingredients like hyaluronic acid, squalane, and plant-based oils that are known to retain moisture and smooth out the skin’s texture. The formula is rich without being too heavy, something I look for in products that promise hydration without greasiness.

My Experience

I use this serum after cleansing and toning in my evening routine, applying a few drops and letting it sink. Right away, I noticed my skin feeling plumper and looking smoother. It can also be used in the morning routine and provide a great base for makeup.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Heavyweight and hydrating, makes skin feel soft and plump, works well under other products.

• Cons: The scent is earthy and may not be for everyone, though I personally love it. The amount is also on the smaller side, so it feels like a bit of a splurge for the price.

These products have shown me why Primally Pure has such a loyal following. With simple ingredients and thoughtful formulations, they’ve made it possible to find truly non-toxic products that don’t compromise on performance.

Use the code Orbasics to save 10% on your Primally Pure order!

primally pure product review Plumping Serum

Brand Overview: Primally Pure’s Mission and Commitment to Clean Beauty

Primally Pure was founded by Bethany McDaniel, inspired by her personal journey to find truly non-toxic skincaresolutions. It all began on her family’s organic farm, where she started crafting simple skincare products free from synthetic additives and artificial fragrances. Bethany’s passion for pure, natural ingredients grew into Primally Pure, a brand built on the belief that skincare should be both effective and uncomplicated.

Commitment to Pure, Natural Ingredients

At the heart of Primally Pure’s philosophy is a commitment to using pure, recognizable ingredients. The brand carefully selects high-quality components, often sourced organically, ensuring each product is free from harmful chemicals andartificial fragrances, making them a great option for those with skin allergies or sensitivities.
Bethany believes in the power of nature to nourish the skin, stating, “Nature knows best and has given us everything we need – no chemicals, fragrances or fillers needed.”

Primally Pure* Product Range

Primally Pure offers a simple yet powerful range of skincare and body care products, each thoughtfully crafted to be effective without unnecessary ingredients.Their product line includes:

• Deodorants: Available in various formulations to suit different skin types and sensitivities.

• Skincare: A range encompassing cleansing oils, toning mists, hydrating masks, and serums, each designed to support skin health naturally.

• Wellness Tools: Items such as dry brushes and facial tools that promote holistic self-care practices.

Some popular products include the Cleansing Oil, Everything Spray, Plumping Mist, Beauty Cream, and Lemongrass Deodorant.

Emu Oil: A Key Ingredient in Primally Pure* Products

One of the unique and standout ingredients in several Primally Pure products is emu oil. It’s an ingredient you don’t often see in mainstream skincare, but Primally Pure includes it in products like their beauty cream, plumping mist and body butter for very specific reasons.

Emu oil is packed with fatty acids and antioxidants, making it a powerful moisturizer and skin-nourisher. It penetrates deeply, working well even for those with dry or mature skin types that need extra hydration. It also has natural anti-inflammatory properties, which is why it’s known to soothe and calm the skin effectively. For anyone dealing with sensitivity, redness, or even irritation from harsher products, emu oil can be a lifesaver, helping to restore balance and comfort to the skin.

Bethany’s approach to product development is deeply rooted in her personal experiences and commitment to clean living. She emphasizes the importance of transparency and integrity in skincare, aiming to provide products that are both safe and effective. As she reflects on her journey, Bethany notes, “We’re rooted in time-tested, traditional perspectives that honor ancient wisdom and animal-based products to guide you in creating transformative results in your daily life.”

For more insights into Bethany’s philosophy and the story behind Primally Pure, you can watch her interview on the Happier & Healthier Podcast:

Customer Experience and Support

Primally Pure’s customer service stands out for its warmth, promptness, and genuine support. Each interaction feels like talking to a team that truly cares about customer experience, whether it’s for ingredient advice or product help. They create a sense of community, making customers feel valued and supported.

Primally Pure Shipping

Primally Pure offers free shipping on orders over $75, which I take advantage of by bundling a few items at a time. They also have a great return policy: returns or exchanges are allowed within 60 days, and beyond that, store credit is provided. Their online form makes returns and exchanges quick and hassle-free, allowing you to try products with confidence.

Is Primally Pure Worth It?

Primally Pure is undoubtedly an investment. The price point is on the higher side, and I’ve noticed that the product sizes can feel a bit small compared to other options. But what you’re getting for the price is something special.

Primally Pure goes above and beyond in quality, both in terms of ingredients and even packaging. Every product feels thoughtfully crafted and is packed with genuinely effective, high-quality ingredients—no fillers or artificial additives, just real, natural components . It’s clear they prioritize the quality of every single ingredient, which I appreciate, especially in a world where “natural” doesn’t always mean non-toxic or effective.

Their eco-friendly packaging, with minimal plastic and sturdy reusable glass jars or recyclable materials, speaks to their commitment to sustainability and quality. This is a brand that seems to care about the impact of its products, both on your skin and the planet.

So, is it worth it? If you’re ready to invest in clean beauty products that deliver real results, then yes, Primally Pure is worth every penny.

Key Takeaways

• Trustworthy Quality: Primally Pure has won me over with the quality and thoughtfulness behind each product. Using high-quality, organic ingredients and simple formulas actually live up to the promise of non-toxic skincare, which is rare to find and feels refreshing.

• Effective, Non-Irritating Formulas: In my years of trying various natural skincare, Primally Pure products stand out because they work without any big downsides. Whether it’s a deodorant that actually controls odor or skincare that nourishes without irritation, these natural, non-toxic skincare products products consistently deliver on their claims.

• Mindful Packaging: I’m a huge fan of their eco-conscious packaging—almost no plastic and everything feels high-quality and sustainable. It’s clear that Primally Pure cares about both the environment and their customers’ health.

• Worth the Investment: I won’t lie, the price can be an investment, especially with the sizes being a bit on the smaller side. But knowing that I’m paying for truly effective, clean ingredients makes it worth it. For me, it’s more than just skincare; it’s a commitment to quality that I’m happy to support.

FAQ to Primally Pure Review

Is primally pure good skin care?

Primally Pure has impressed me with natural, high-quality but simple ingredients. For me, their products have become essentials in my routine, nourishing the skin, especially because they’re effective without being harsh.

Is Primally Pure safe?

I feel confident using Primally Pure because they’re committed to natural, non-toxic ingredients. It’s reassuring to know what I’m putting on my skin is simple and safe, especially with sensitive skin.

Is Primally Pure a good deodorant?

Yes, their deodorants are ones of the best I’ve tried in the natural category for odor control, even if they may leave a little residue on darker clothes. For me, it’s been worth it to finally find a deodorant that works without irritation.

Lilija Bairamova

Lilija is the founder of Orbasics, a brand born from her passion for creating a healthier, more sustainable world, starting with organic, toxin-free clothing for children. As a mother committed to a non-toxic lifestyle, Lilija has spent years exploring and embracing clean beauty, non-toxic living, and holistic wellness. She shares her expertise on everything from natural personal care to creating toxin-free home environments, offering practical tips and in-depth guides that empower you to make healthier choices and lead a more mindful, health-conscious life.